Skillware · ARCHITECTURAL COMPARISON & BENCHMARKS
Architectural Comparison: Skillware vs MCP, LangChain, AutoGen & Semantic Kernel
Most agent ecosystems treat capabilities as open-ended prompts, external RPC servers, or dynamic code generation. Skillware packages capabilities as deterministic Python skills with typed contracts, pre-execution gates, and cryptographic AURA verification.
Concrete Task Benchmark: Five Architectural Paths
Evaluating five approaches on identical production wallet screening workflows:
- Skillware (finance/wallet_screening): Latency <1.0s · Token Cost: Zero · Determinism: High · Security: High · Setup: Easy
- Model Context Protocol (MCP): Latency <1.0s · Token Cost: Low · Determinism: Ok · Security: Med · Setup: Hard
- LangChain Tool Wrappers: Latency <10s · Token Cost: Med · Determinism: Med · Security: Low · Setup: Hard
- Dynamic Code Generation: Latency <60s · Token Cost: High · Determinism: Low · Security: Low · Setup: Low
- Raw Prompt Engineering: Latency <20s · Token Cost: High · Determinism: Low · Security: Med · Setup: Med
The Five First-Class Primitives
- Contract (manifest.yaml): Typed I/O, permissions, pre-execution parameters validation.
- Effect (skill.py): Hermetic, offline deterministic execution with bound memory.
- Directive (instructions.md): Progressive disclosure SOPs injected only when the skill is called.
- Assurance (test_skill.py): Schema consistency invariants, pytest fixtures, and AST safety verification.
- Corpus (data/): Local air-gapped domain lexicons and reference tables.